Sandwiches

Our Sandwiches come in two sizes
Normal (4 ounces) or Deli Size (almost 8 ounces)

Reubens

• 1

  Katzinger’s Reuben

  Our best-selling sandwich since the day we opened. Hot corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, our own Russian dressing grilled on rye.
  $14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95

• 16

  Be’s Bustling Birdwich

  Oven-roasted turkey breast, Swiss cheese, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing grilled on rye.
  $13.75 | Deli Size: $16.95

• 17

  Steve’s Cross Currents

  Hot corned beef, chopped chicken liver, Swiss cheese, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing on rye.
  $14.45 | Deli Size: $16.95

• 21

  Gene’s Free Lunch

  Hot corned beef, rosemary and garlic roast beef, Swiss cheese, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing on pumpernickel.
  $14.00 | Deli Size: $16.95

• 27

  Judy and Jerry’s Sunday Supper

  Hot corned beef, creamy coleslaw, Swiss cheese, Russian dressing grilled on rye.
  $14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95

• 30

  Lewis’s Titillating, Litigating Lunch

  Hot, slow-cooked brisket, Swiss cheese, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing, grilled on rye.
  $15.00 | Deli Size: $18.25

• 31

  Big Bob’s Belly Balancer

  Hot corned beef, hot pastrami, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing on rye.
  $14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95

• 34

  Neal’s Let’s Make A Meal

  Rosemary and garlic roast beef, slow-cooked brisket, white cheddar, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing grilled on rye.
  $14.45 | Deli Size: $18.45

• 37

  Ko and Shoogy Special

  Hot corned beef, oven-roasted turkey breast, Swiss cheese, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing on pumpernickel.
  $14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95

• 39

  Bill, Gary and Beuford’s Upper Yough Reuben

  Featured on the Food Network’s Best Thing I Ever Ate! Hot pastrami, Swiss cheese, choice of sauerkraut or creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing grilled on rye.
  $14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95

BLTs & CLUBS

• 33

  Becker’s Belt ‘Em

  The best egg salad in town – Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise on rye.
  $12.75 | Deli Size: $14.95

• 41

  Phil’s Katzinger’s Club

  Homemade chicken salad, Applewood smoked bacon, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, Honeycup mustard on rye.
  $14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95

• 44

  Marigene’s Meal of Fortune

  Smoked turkey breast, Applewood smoked bacon, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, Dijon mustard, grilled on rye.
  $14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95

• 62

  Frank’s Reincarnation

  Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayonnaise on toasted rye.
  $14.45 | Deli Size: $16.95

• 69

  Jack Does the Funky Chicken

  Grilled, marinated chicken breast, Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, Honeycup mustard, grilled on sourdough.
  $15.45 | Deli Size: $17.95

• 70

  Kahrl’s Killer Club

  Oven-roasted turkey breast, honey ham, Applewood smoked bacon, white cheddar, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise on three slices toasted challah.
  $15.45 | Deli Size: $17.95

• 75

  Kathy and Jim Float Away

  Applewood smoked bacon, white cheddar, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise grilled on farm bread.
  $15.45 | Deli Size: $17.95

• 79

  Todd is My Co-Pilot

  Grilled marinated chicken breast, Applewood smoked bacon, sliced avocado, lettuce, tomato, red onion, homemade ranch dressing on farm bread.
  $15.75 | Deli Size: $18.95

• 80

  Misty and Stef Rule the World

  Applewood smoked bacon, provolone cheese, lettuce, sun-dried tomato, homemade pesto-mayo on toasted farm bread.
  $15.45 | Deli Size: $17.95

Fish and Eggs

• 5

  Mimi’s Melody

  Homemade tuna salad, white cheddar, tomato, Russian dressing, grilled on rye.
  $12.45 | Deli Size: $14.95

• 10

  Lindey’s Come Again

  Tender smoked nova salmon, scallion cream cheese, tomato, red onion on pumpernickel.
  $15.25 | Deli Size: $18.95

• 15

  Auntie F’s Mackinaw Monster

  Smoked whitefish salad, scallion cream cheese, tomato, red onion on pumpernickel.
  $16.45 | Deli Size: $18.25

• 60

  Here’s Jeanne Again

  Smoked Nova salmon, cream cheese, tomato, red onion on a bagel.
  $15.45 | Deli Size: $17.95

• 74

  Wross Left his Mark

  Homemade tuna salad made with water-packed white albacore tuna, lettuce, and tomato on rye.
  $12.45 | Deli Size: $14.95

Vegetarian and Vegan

• 54

  Doug’s Vegetarian Head Plant (vegan)

  Our garlicky marinated artichoke hearts, roasted red pepper, spinach, cucumber, lettuce, tomato on harvest grain bread.
  $12.45 | Deli Size: $14.95

• 55

  Fred’s Jazzy Treata (vegan)

  Homemade hummus, cucumbers, spinach, tomato, Greek Kalamata olives on harvest grain bread.
  $12.45 | Deli Size: $14.95

• 57

  Franklin’s Kibbetz

  Katzinger’s homemade fresh mozzarella, tomato, our own homemade pesto, grilled on sourdough.
  $13.45 | Deli Size: $15.95

• 71

  Good Enough for Jan to Paint

  Cave-aged Gruyère, grilled red onion, tomato, Dijon mustard grilled on farm bread.
  $14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95

• 78

  Seth’s Bella MushReuben

  Marinated sliced portabella mushroom, Swiss cheese, creamy cole slaw, Russian dressing, grilled on rye.
  $13.45 | Deli Size: $15.95

Keeping It Simple
(one filling + simple additions)

• 46

  Repast of the Robber Baron

  Oven-roasted turkey breast, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise on rye.
  $12.75 | Deli Size: $15.95

• 63

  Memories of Morris

  Hot corned beef, hot mustard on rye.
  $13.45 | Deli Size: $15.95

• 64

  There’s Nothin’ Like Naima

  Hot pastrami, hot mustard on rye.
  $13.45 | Deli Size: $16.25

• 66

  Bob says “Ella Makes My Day”

  Rosemary and garlic roast beef, lettuce, tomato, Katzinger’s own horseradish sauce on challah.
  $14.45 | Deli Size: $16.95

• 67

  Chuck’s Favorite Editorial

  Homemade chicken salad, lettuce, tomato on rye.
  $12.75 | Deli Size: $14.95

• 77

  Peggy’s Legend

  Pickled tongue, lettuce, tomato, Russian dressing on rye.
  $15.45 | Deli Size: $19.95

More Deli Masterpieces

• 3

  Ari’s Open Door

  Hot pastrami, all beef hard salami, Swiss cheese, cream cheese on pumpernickel.
  $14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95

• 7

  Lonny & Sonny’s Concoction

  Oven-roasted turkey breast, thinly sliced prosciutto, scallion cream cheese, Dijon mustard on rye.
  $15.00 | Deli Size: $18.95

• 8

  Mom & Granny’s Harbor Hero

  Homemade chicken salad, Muenster cheese, lettuce, tomato on a challah.
  $14.45 | Deli Size: $15.95

• 9

  Jimmy’s Photo Finish

  Hot pastrami, Swiss cheese, red onion, hot mustard, grilled on rye.
  $14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95

• 11

  Janis’ Special Can-Do

  Smoked turkey breast, Muenster cheese, Honeycup mustard, grilled on challah.
  $13.45 | Deli Size: $15.95

• 12

  Norman’s Special II

  Rosemary and garlic roast beef, oven-roasted turkey breast, Muenster cheese, lettuce, red onion, Russian dressing on rye.
  $13.45 | Deli Size: $16.95

• 29

  Jeff’s Soaring Super Sandwich

  Hot corned beef, hot pastrami, Swiss cheese, hot mustard on rye.
  $14.25 | Deli Size: $17.50

• 32

  Andy’s Got Another Job

  Smoked turkey breast, honey ham, scallion cream cheese, tomato, Honeycup mustard on rye.
  $14.95 | Deli Size: $16.95

• 51

  Cousin Barbara’s Balancing Act

  Grilled, marinated chicken breast, white cheddar, lettuce, spicy peppers in oil, grilled on rye with a side of sour cream.
  $14.45 | Deli Size: $16.95

• 58

  Sam Lives Here

  Oven roasted turkey breast, honey ham, lettuce, tomato, hot mustard, mayonnaise on harvest grain bread.
  $13.75 | Deli Size: $16.95

• 59

  President Bill’s Day at the Deli

  Hot corned beef, Swiss cheese, hot mustard on pumpernickel. (created by President Clinton himself!).
  $14.00 | Deli Size: $16.95

• 65

  Rachel & Nicki Got Stuck in a Closet

  Hot, slow-cooked brisket slathered with homemade sweet and tangy BBQ sauce, creamy coleslaw, Swiss cheese on a Challah roll.
  $15.45 | Deli Size: $19.00

• 68

  When Katzinger’s Turned Twenty!

  Grilled, marinated chicken breast, white cheddar, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise on farm bread.
  $13.75 | Deli Size: $15.95

• 76

  Mike and Rich Follow the Bubble

  Capicola, sopressata Italian salami, provolone, lettuce, roasted red pepper, herbed oil served on a warm baguette.
  $15.45 | Deli Size: $18.95