Our Sandwiches come in two sizes
Normal (4 ounces) or Deli Size (almost 8 ounces)
Corned Beef
-
1
Katzinger’s Reuben
Our best-selling sandwich since the day we opened. Corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, our own Russian dressing, grilled on rye.
$14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95 -
17
Steve’s Cross-Currents
Hot corned beef, chopped liver, Swiss cheese, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing on rye.
$14.45 | Deli Size: $16.95 -
21
Gene’s Free Lunch
Hot corned beef, roast beef, Swiss cheese, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing on pumpernickel.
$14.00 | Deli Size: $16.95 -
27
Judy and Jerry’s Sunday Supper
Hot corned beef, creamy coleslaw, Swiss cheese, Russian dressing, grilled on rye.
$14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95 -
29
Jeff’s Soaring Super Sandwich
Hot corned beef, hot pastrami, Swiss cheese, hot mustard on rye.
$14.25 | Deli Size: $17.50 -
31
Big Bob’s Belly Balancer
Hot corned beef, hot pastrami, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing on rye.
$14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95 -
37
Ko and Shoogy Special
Hot corned beef, oven-roasted turkey, Swiss cheese, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing on pumpernickel.
$14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95 -
59
President Bill’s Day at the Deli
Hot corned beef, Swiss cheese, hot mustard on pumpernickel (created by President Clinton himself!)
$14.00 | Deli Size: $16.95 -
63
Memories of Morris
Hot corned beef, spicy mustard on rye.
$13.45 | Deli Size: $15.95
Pastrami
-
3
Ari’s Open Door
Hot pastrami, all-beef hard salami, Swiss cheese, cream cheese on pumpernickel.
$14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95 -
9
Jimmy’s Photo Finish
Hot pastrami, Swiss cheese, red onion, hot mustard, grilled on rye.
$14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95 -
29
Jeff’s Soaring Super Sandwich
Hot corned beef, hot pastrami, Swiss cheese, hot mustard on rye.
$14.25 | Deli Size: $17.50 -
31
Big Bob’s Belly Balancer
Hot corned beef, hot pastrami, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing on rye.
$14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95 -
39
Bill, Gary and Beauford’s Upper Yough Reuben
Featured on the FOOD NETWORK’S BEST THING I EVER ATE! Hot pastrami, Swiss cheese, your choice of sauerkraut or creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing grilled on rye.
$14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95 -
64
There’s Nothin’ Like Naima
Hot pastrami, spicy mustard on rye.
$13.45 | Deli Size: $16.25 -
76
Mike & Rich Follow the Bubble
Capicola, sopressata salami, provolone, lettuce, roasted red pepper, herbed oil served on a warm baguette. Please allow us a few extra minutes to prepare this sandwich.
$15.45 | Deli Size: $18.95
Roast Beef and Brisket
-
12
Norman’s Special II
Roast beef, oven-roasted turkey, Muenster cheese, lettuce, red onion, Russian dressing on rye.
$13.45 | Deli Size: $16.95 -
21
Gene’s Free Lunch
Hot corned beef, roast beef, Swiss cheese, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing on pumpernickel.
$14.00 | Deli Size: $16.95 -
30
Lewis’ Titillating, Litigating Lunch
Hot slow-cooked brisket, Swiss cheese, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing, grilled on rye.
$15.00 | Deli Size: $18.25 -
34
Neal’s Let’s Make A Meal
Rosemary and garlic roast beef, warm slow-cooked brisket, Vermont white cheddar, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing grilled on rye.
$14.45 | Deli Size: $18.45 -
65
Rachel & Nicki Got Stuck in a Closet
Hot slow-cooked brisket slathered with homemade sweet and tangy BBQ sauce, creamy coleslaw, Swiss cheese on a Challah roll.
$15.45 | Deli Size: $19.00 -
66
Bob Says “Ella Makes My Day”
Rosemary and garlic roast beef, lettuce, tomato Katzinger’s own horseradish sauce on challah.
$14.45 | Deli Size: $16.95
Oven Roasted & Smoked Turkey
-
7
Lonny & Sonny’s Concoction
Roasted turkey, prosciutto, scallion cream cheese, Dijon mustard on rye.
$15.00 | Deli Size: $18.95 -
11
Janis’ Special Can-Do
Smoked turkey, Muenster cheese, Honeycup mustard, grilled on challah.
$13.45 | Deli Size: $15.95 -
12
Norman’s Special II
Roast beef, oven-roasted turkey, Muenster cheese, lettuce, red onion, Russian dressing on rye.
$13.45 | Deli Size: $16.95 -
16
Be’s Bustling Birdwich
Oven-roasted turkey, Swiss cheese, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing grilled on rye.
$13.75 | Deli Size: $16.95 -
32
Andy’s Got Another Job
Smoked turkey, honey ham, scallion cream cheese, tomato, Honeycup mustard on rye.
$14.95 | Deli Size: $16.95 -
37
Ko and Shoogy Special
Hot corned beef, oven-roasted turkey, Swiss cheese, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing on pumpernickel.
$14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95 -
44
Marigene’s Meal of Fortune
Smoked turkey, Applewood smoked bacon, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, Dijon mustard grilled on rye.
$14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95 -
46
Repast of the Robber Baron
Turkey breast, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise on rye.
$12.75 | Deli Size: $15.95 -
58
Sam Lives Here
Oven-roasted turkey breast, honey ham, hot mustard, mayonnaise on whole grain bread.
$13.75 | Deli Size: $16.95 -
70
Kahrl’s Killer Club
Oven-roasted turkey breast, Applewood smoked ham, Vermont white cheddar, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise on three slices of toasted challah.
$15.45 | Deli Size: $17.95
BLTs & Egg Salad
-
33
Becker’s Belt ‘Em
Egg salad with applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise on rye.
$12.75 | Deli Size: $14.95 -
62
Frank’s Reincarnation
Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise on toasted rye.
$14.45 | Deli Size: $16.95 -
75
Kathy and Jim Float Away
Applewood smoked bacon, white cheddar, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise grilled on farm bread.
$15.45 | Deli Size: $17.95
Grilled Chicken & Homemade Chicken Salad
-
41
Phil’s Katzinger’s Club
Homemade chicken salad, applewood smoked bacon, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, Honeycup mustard on rye.
$14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95 -
67
Chuck’s Favorite Editorial
Homemade chicken salad, lettuce, tomato on rye.
$12.75 | Deli Size: $14.95 -
68
When Katzinger’s Turned Twenty!
Marinated and grilled Amish chicken breast, Vermont white cheddar, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise on farm bread.
$13.75 | Deli Size: $15.95 -
69
Jack Does the Funky Chicken
Grilled marinated chicken breast, applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, Honeycup mustard grilled on sourdough.
$15.45 | Deli Size: $17.95 -
79
Todd is My Co-Pilot
Grilled marinated chicken breast, applewood smoked bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato, red onion, homemade ranch dressing on farm bread.
$15.75 | Deli Size: $18.95
Smoked Salmon & Tuna Salad
-
5
Mimi’s Melody
Homemade tuna salad, white cheddar, tomato, Russian dressing grilled on rye.
$12.45 | Deli Size: $14.95 -
10
Lindey’s Come Again
Smoked Nova salmon, scallion cream cheese, tomato, red onion on pumpernickel.
$15.25 | Deli Size: $18.95 -
60
Here’s Jeanne Again
Smoked Nova salmon, cream cheese, tomato, red onion on a bagel of your choice.
$15.45 | Deli Size: $17.95 -
74
Wross Left His Mark
Homemade tuna salad made with water-packed white albacore tuna, lettuce and tomato on rye.
$12.45 | Deli Size: $14.95
Vegetarian / Vegan
-
54
Doug’s Vegetarian Head Plant (Vegan)
Our own garlicky marinated artichoke hearts, roasted red pepper, spinach, cucumber, tomato on Harvest Grain bread.
$12.45 | Deli Size: $14.95 -
55
Fred’s Jazzy Treata (Vegan)
Homemade hummus, cucumbers, spinach, tomato, Greek Kalamata olives on Harvest Grain bread.
$12.45 | Deli Size: $14.95 -
57
Franklin’s Kibbetz
Katzinger’s homemade fresh mozzarella, tomato, our homemade basil pesto grilled on sourdough.
$13.45 | Deli Size: $15.95 -
78
Seth’s Bella Mushreuben
Marinated sliced portabella mushroom, Swiss cheese, creamy coleslaw, Russian dressing grilled on rye.
$13.45 | Deli Size: $15.95
Can’t Choose?
Try One of Our Best Sellers
-
1
Katzinger’s Reuben
Our best-selling sandwich since the day we opened. Corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, our own Russian dressing, grilled on rye.
$14.45 | Deli Size: $17.95 -
11
Janis’ Special Can-Do
Smoked turkey, Muenster cheese, Honeycup mustard, grilled on challah.
$13.45 | Deli Size: $15.95 -
70
Kahrl’s Killer Club
Oven-roasted turkey breast, Applewood smoked ham, Vermont white cheddar, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise on three slices of toasted challah.
$15.45 | Deli Size: $17.95 -
76
Mike & Rich Follow the Bubble
Capicola, sopressata salami, provolone, lettuce, roasted red pepper, herbed oil served on a warm baguette. Please allow us a few extra minutes to prepare this sandwich.
$15.45 | Deli Size: $18.95
Deli-News
Sign Up Here
"*" indicates required fields