Choose from two sizes - "The Bigger One" - nearly a 1/2 pound of scrumptious filling piled on our never duplicated hand sliced Katzinger's Bakehoue Breads,  or the slightly smaller "Big One" - nearly a 1/4 pound of the same luscious filling on slightly smaller slices of bread.  All sandwiches come with our fresh from the pickle barrel dill. Choose from traditional "old" or garlicky "new".
Corned Beef cooked right here... Pastrami imported from Brooklyn. Chopped Liver as good as grandma's. Big Bigger
#1  Katzinger's Reuben - Hot Corned Beef, Swiss Cheese, Imported Sauerkraut, Russian Dressing on hand-sliced Jewish rye grilled to perfection 9.95 11.95
#3  Ari's Open Door - Hot Pastrami, all-beef Hard Salami, Swiss Cheese, Cream Cheese On hand-sliced Pumpernickel 9.95 11.75
#9 Jimmy's Photo Finish -Hot pastrami, Swiss cheese, sweet red onion, spicy brown mustard, grilled on hand-sliced rye 9.25 11.25
#17  Steve's Cross Currents -Hot corned Beef, chopped chicken Liver, Swiss cheese, Cole Slaw, Russian Dressing on hand-sliced Jewish Rye 9.95 11.75
#21  Gene's Free Lunch - Hot Corned Beef, Roast Beef, Swiss Cheese, Cole Slaw, Russian Dressing on Pumpernickel 10.50 12.50
#27  Judy and Jerry's Sunday Supper - Hot Corned Beef, Swiss cheese, Cole Slaw, Russian Dressing, grilled on hand-sliced Jewish Rye 9.95 11.95
#29  Jeff's Soaring Super Sandwich -Hot Corned Beef, Hot Pastrami, Swiss Cheese, Hot Mustard on Rye 9.75 11.75
#31  Big Bob's Belly Balancer - Hot Corned Beef, Hot Pastrami, Cole Slaw, Russian Dressing on Rye 9.75 11.95
#37  Ko and Shoogy Special - Hot Corned Beef, Turkey breast, Swiss cheese, Cole Slaw, Russian Dressing on Pumpernickel 10.25 12.25
#39  Billy, Gary & Beuford's Upper Yough Reuben -Hot Pastrami, Swiss cheese, Sauerkraut or Cole Slaw, Russian Dressing grilled on Pumpernickel 9.75 11.75
#59  President Bill's Day at the Deli -Hot Corned Beef, Swiss cheese, Hot Mustard on Pumpernickel 9.25 11.25
#63  Memories of Morris  -Hot corned beef, spicy mustard on hand-sliced Jewish rye 8.95 10.50
#64  There's Nothin' Like Naima  -Hot Pastrami, spicy mustard on hand- sliced Jewish rye 8.75 10.25
#77  Peggy's Legend  -Pickled tongue, lettuce, tomato, Russian dressing on hand-sliced rye 9.25 11.25

Roast beef blessed with garlic and rosemary... brisket marinated 48 hours - tender as can be. Big Bigger
#12  Norman's Special II - Roast Beef, Turkey Breast, Muenster Cheese, Lettuce, Red Onion, Russian Dressing on hand sliced Jewish Rye 10.50 12.50
#21  Gene's Free Lunch - Hot Corned Beef, Roast Beef, Swiss cheese, Cole Slaw, homemade Russian Dressing on pumpernickel 10.50 12.50
#30  Lewis' Titillating, Litigating Lunch - Hot Brisket, Swiss cheese, creamy Cole Slaw, Russian Dressing grilled on Jewish Rye 10.25 12.25
#34  Neal's Let's Make a Meal -Roast Beef, Hot Brisket, Vermont Cheddar, Cole Slaw, Russian Dressing grilled on Jewish Rye 10.25 12.25
#65  Rachel & Nicki Got Stuck in a Closet  -Hot slow-cooked  brisket slathered with Sara's BBQ sauce, cole slaw, Swiss cheese on a Kaiser roll 10.25 12.25
#66  Bob says "Ella Makes My Day" -Rosemary and garlic Roast beef, lettuce, tomato, Katzinger's own  horseradish sauce on hand sliced challah.   10.25 12.25

This turkey breast is the real thing - not pressed or rolled.  We carefully season & lovingly roast each breast to a tender, juicy finish Big Bigger
#7  Lonny & Sonny's Concoction -Turkey Breast, thinly sliced Proscuitto, Scallion Cream Cheese, Dijon Mustard on hand sliced Rye 10.25 12.25
#11  Janis' Special Can-Do -Smoked Turkey Breast, Muenster Cheese, Canadian Honeycup Mustard grilled on hand-sliced Challah 10.25 12.25
#12  Norman's Special II - Roast Beef, Turkey Breast, Muenster Cheese, Lettuce, Red Onion, Russian Dressing on hand-sliced Jewish Rye 10.50 12.50
#16  Be's Bustling Birdwich -Oven-roasted Turkey Breast, Swiss cheese, creamy Cole Slaw, Russian Dressing grilled on hand-sliced Jewish Rye 9.95 11.95
#32  Andy's Got Another Job -Smoked Turkey Breast, Honey Ham, Scallion Cream Cheese, Tomato, Honeycup Mustard on hand-sliced Rye 10.25 11.95
#37  Ko and Shoogy Special -Hot Corned Beef, Turkey Breast, Switzerland Swiss, Cole Slaw, and our own Russian Dressing on pumpernickel 10.25 12.25
#44  Marigene's Meal of Fortune -Smoked Turkey Breast, sweet, smokey Applewood  Bacon,  Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Hellman's Mayonnaise, Dijon mustard grilled on hand-sliced Rye 10.50 12.50
#46  Repast of the Robber Baron -Turkey Breast, Lettuce, Tomato, Hellman's Mayonnaise on hand-sliced Jewish Rye 8.95 10.75
#58  Sam Lives Here -Oven-roasted Turkey Breast, Honey Ham, Lettuce, Tomato, Hot Mustard, Hellman's Mayonnaise on hand sliced whole wheat 9.75 11.75
#70 Kahrl's Killer Club -Oven roasted turkey breast, Honey Ham, Applewood smoked bacon, Vermont white cheddar, lettuce, tomato, Hellman's mayonnaise on toasted hand-sliced challah 10.50 12.50

Big Bigger
#3  Ari's Open Door -Hot Pastrami, all-beef hard salami, Swiss cheese, Cream Cheese on hand-sliced Pumpernickel 9.75 11.75
#7  Lonny & Sonny's Concoction -Turkey Breast, Proscuitto, Scallion Cream Cheese, Dijon Mustard on hand-sliced Rye 10.25 12.25
#32  Andy's Got Another Job -Smoked Turkey Breast, Honey Ham, Scallion Cream Cheese, Tomato, Honeycup Mustard on hand-sliced Rye 10.25 12.25
#44  Marigene's Meal of Fortune -Smoked Turkey Breast, sweet, smokey Applewood  Bacon,  Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Hellman's Mayonnaise, Dijon mustard grilled on hand-sliced Rye 10.50 12.50
#58  Sam Lives Here -Turkey Breast, Baked Ham, Lettuce, Tomato, Spicy Mustard, Hellman's Mayonnaise on Whole Wheat 9.75 11.75
#62  Frank's Reincarnation -Sweet, smokey Applewood  Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato & Hellman's mayonnaise on toasted  Rye 9.95 11.75
#69  Jen Does the Funky Chicken -Grilled chicken breast marinated in balsamic vinegar and Honeycup mustard, Applewood Smoked bacon, Vermont white cheddar, lettuce, tomato, Hellman's mayonnaise, Honeycup mustard, grilled on hand-sliced sourdough 10.50 12.50
#70 Kahrl's Killer Club -Oven roasted turkey breast, Honey Ham, Applewood smoked bacon, Vermont white cheddar, lettuce, tomato, Hellman's mayonnaise on toasted hand-sliced challah 10.50 12.50
#75  Kathy and Jim Float Away -Applewood smoked bacon, Vermont white cheddar, lettuce, tomato, Hellman's mayonnaise grilled on hand-sliced Farm Bread 9.95 11.75
#76  Mike and Rich Follow the Bubble -Capicola, soppresatta, provolone, lettuce, roasted red pepper, herbed oil served on a warm baguette 9.95 11.75
Applewood Smoked Bacon? You won't believe how good it is.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Gerber chicken's are meticulously cared for by Amish families, fed a vegetarian diet with no hormones or artificial ingredients.  This chicken tastes like real chicken should! Big Bigger
#8  Mom & Granny's Harbor Hero -Homemade Chicken Salad,  Muenster Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato on a Croissant 9.95 11.95
#41  Phil's Katzinger Club -Homemade Chicken Salad, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Swiss cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Hellman's mayonnaise, Honeycup mustard on hand-sliced Rye 10.50 12.25
#51  Cousin Barbara's Balancing Act -Grilled chicken breast marinated in balsamic vinegar and Honeycup mustard, Vermont white cheddar, lettuce, Spicy peppers in oil, grilled on hand-sliced rye with a side of sour cream.  10.50 12.50
#67 Chuck's Favorite Editorial -Homemade chicken salad, lettuce, tomato, on hand-sliced rye. 7.75 9.50
#68 Katzinger's Turns Twenty! -Marinated and grilled Amish chicken breast, Vermont white cheddar, lettuce,  tomato, Hellman's mayonnaise on hand-sliced Farm Bread  10.50 12.50
#69  Jen Does the Funky Chicken -Grilled chicken breast marinated in balsamic vinegar and Honeycup mustard, Applewood Smoked bacon, Vermont white cheddar, lettuce, tomato, Hellman's mayonnaise, Honeycup mustard, grilled on hand-sliced sourdough 10.50 12.50
     
     
     
     

. Big Bigger
#5 Mimi's Melody -Homemade tuna salad, Vermont white cheddar, tomato, Russian dressing, grilled on hand-sliced rye. 8.75 10.50
#10  Lindey's Come Again -Tender smoked nova salmon, Scallion Cream Cheese, Tomato, Red Onion on Pumpernickel 9.25 11.25
#15  Auntie F's Mackinaw Monster - Smoked Whitefish Salad, Scallion Cream Cheese, Tomato, Onion on Pumpernickel 9.95 11.75
#33  Becker's Belt 'Em -The best egg salad in town, Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, Hellman's mayonnaise on rye. 7.95 9.75
#38 Sue and Mike's This I Would Eat -Homemade tuna salad, muenster cheese, tomato, sweet onion, Dijon mustard, grilled on hand sliced challah.   8.25 9.95
#60  Here's Jeanne Again -Smoked Nova Salmon, Cream Cheese, Tomato, Onion on a Bagel 7.75 9.50
#61  Twin's Peekin' - Smoked Whitefish Filet, cream cheese, tomato and onion on a Bagel 8.75 9.75
#74 Wross Left his Mark -Homemade tuna salad made with water-packed white albacore tuna, lettuce, tomato, on hand sliced rye. 7.50 9.25
     

Big Bigger
#54  Doug's Vegetarian Head-Plant -(vegan) Our garlicky marinated Artichoke Hearts, Roasted Red Pepper, Spinach, Cucumber, Lettuce, Tomato in a Pita 7.95 9.75
#55  Fred's Jazzy Pita Treata -(vegan) Homemade Hummus, Cucumbers, Spinach, Tomato, Greek Kalamata Olives in Pita 6.95 8.75
#57  Franklin's Kibbetz -Katzinger's Homemade Fresh Mozzarella, our own Homemade Pesto, Tomato grilled on Sourdough 8.95 10.95
#71 Good Enough for Jan to Paint -Cave aged Gruyere, sweet onion, tomato, dijon mustard  grilled on hand-sliced Farm Bread 9.25 11.25
#72 The Good, The Bad and The Lawyer -Marinated grilled sliced portabella mushroom, oven roasted vegetables, spinach, grilled on hand-sliced Farm Bread 9.25 11.25
#73 Ali's O's. Portawich -Marinated, grilled, sliced, portabella mushroom, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, balsamic vinaigrette, on hand-sliced whole wheat 9.25 10.50
     

 
Homemade Chicken Broth    1.95
with Noodles    2.50
with Homemade Matzo Balls    2.95
Seth's Soup of the Day -Please call    Priced Daily
1/4 lb. all beef Hot Dog    3.95
Sauerkraut      .75
Cole Slaw      .75

Fresh Fruit Salad seasonal seasonal
Zapp's Potato Chips 3.50/bag
Redskin Potato Salad 2.50 1/2lb.side 4.99 lb
Katzinger's Traditional Potato Salad 2.50 1/2lb. side 4.99 lb
Creamy Cole Slaw 2.50 1/2lb. side 4.99 lb
Macaroni Salad 2.50 1/2lb. side 4.99 lb
Greek Salad Side 3.50 1/2lb.side 7.00 lb

Potato Latke - grated potato and onion pancake, served with sour cream or applesauce. 2.50
Potato Knish - Traditional Eastern European peasant food - pastry dough surrounding a mashed potato filling served with spicy mustard 2.75
Noodle Kugel - a slightly sweet and very comforting noodle pudding. Choose Apricot or Sour Cherry 2.95
Cheese Blintz - a crepe with a sweet cheese filling served with preserves or sour cream 2.50
Chopped Liver - Made with chicken livers, caramelized onion and real schmaltz. Served Rye heels 3.75
Marinated or Creamed Herring - served with Rye Slice 4.50
Smoked Fish Plate - Sable, Chub or Whitefish, wedge of Brie, Fresh Fruit, Rye Slice. A hearty brunch or light dinner. 12.95

In addition to our menu salads, we have a large repertoire - over 200 - of specialty salads from all cultures and cuisines.  Every day we present several to choose from.  Call 614.228.3354 for today's selection or 48 hours in advance to select your favorite.
Grilled Chicken and Artichoke Salad - Grilled chicken breast, marinated artichoke hearts, Emmenthaler Swiss cheese, roasted red pepper strips, tomato slices, sweet onion rings and walnuts on salad greens. Served with sourdough bread and your choice of dressing 11.25
Grilled Portabella Salad -Marinated grilled sliced portabella mushroom on salad greens, creamy fresh goat cheese, oven-roasted vegetables, tomato and sweet onion slices, Kalamata olives. Served with farm bread and your choice of dressing 10.50
The Antipasto Aficionado -Honey ham, Italian style soppresetta and capicola salamis, provolone, mozzarella, roasted red pepper slices, imported olives, tomato slices on romaine.  Served with hand-sliced Rustic Italian bread 10.50
Chicken Salad Platter - Katzinger's homemade Chicken Salad on a leaf lettuce bed, garnished with cucumbers, tomatoes, Kalamata olives, served with bread 7.95
Tuna Salad Platter - Katzinger's homemade Tuna Salad on a leaf lettuce bed, garnished with cucumbers, tomatoes, Kalamata olives, served with bread 7.95
Egg Salad Platter - Katzinger's homemade Egg Salad on a leaf lettuce bed  with cucumbers, tomatoes, Kalamata olives, served with hand-sliced rye bread 5.95
Katzinger's Specialty Cheese Board -A selection of three "just right" cheeses with melon, grapes and strawberries. Served with a baguette.  Can't decide? Let us choose!

Choose from: Cave-Aged Gruyere from Switzerland, Manchego Curado From Spain, Stilton from Great Britain, Cashel Blue from Ireland, Keen's Cheddar from England, Shelbourne cheddar from Vermont, Fromage d'Affinois from France, Humbolt Fog from California, (occasionally we may need to substitute equally wonderful cheeses because of availability)   

 11.95
Whitefish Salad Platter - Katzinger's homemade Whitefish Salad on a leaf lettuce bed, with cucumbers, tomatoes, black olives, served with bread 10.95
Katzinger's Greek Salad - Tangy feta cheese chunks, marinated artichoke hearts, roasted red pepper strips, tomato, cucumber, sweet onion slices, and imported Kalamata olives.  Served with hand-sliced rustic Italian bread & Greek dressing. 9.25
Katzinger's Chef Salad -extra lean corned beef, oven-roasted turkey breast, Emmenthaler Swiss cheese on a bed of greens with tomato and hard boiled egg slices, served with bread and a choice of dressing 10.50
Tossed Salad - an individual side salad with a choice of dressing 2.95
Homemade dressings - Balsamic Vinaigrette, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Extra Virgin Olive Oil & Vinegar, Russian, Blue Cheese, Ranch, Greek.

Special breakfast prices available until 10:30 AM Monday - Saturday & Until 2:00 PM on Sunday Special price Regular Price
Smoked Fish Plate - Sable, Chub or Whitefish, wedge of Brie, Fresh Fruit, Rye Slice 11.95 12.95
#33  Becker's Belt 'Em -The best egg salad in town, Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, Hellman's mayonnaise on rye. 8.75 9.75
#60  Here's Jeanne Again -Smoked Nova Salmon, Cream Cheese, Tomato, sweet onion on a open-faced  bagel 8.50 9.50
#61  Twin's Peekin' - Tender sweet Smoked Whitefish filet, Cream Cheese, tomato, onion on a Bagel 8.75 9.75
#62  Frank's Reincarnation -Sweet smokey Applewood  Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato & Hellman's mayonnaise on toasted  Rye 10.75 11.75
Two Cheese Blintzes with Preserves or Sour Cream 4.90 5.90
Bagel    1.25
Bagel with Butter    1.50
Bagel with Cream Cheese    1.95
Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese (lite available)    2.25
Fresh Bread -Hand Sliced Rye, Pumpernickel, Sourdough, Farm Bread, Challah Toast or Honey Wheat toast with butter.    1.95
Sticky Bun (we recommend them grilled and gooey)    2.50
Croissant    2.25

-all's kid's sandwiches served on Challah - a traditional Jewish white egg bread.
Noah's Grilled American Cheese 3.50
Kid's  All-Beef Bologna 3.75
Kid's All-Beef Soft Salami 3.75
Kid's Turkey 3.75
Kid's Hot Dog 3.95
Kid's PB & Preserves 3.75
Kid's Bagel w/ Cream Cheese and American Spoon Preserves 2.25
Chocolate Milk 1.50

*Every item - every cheesecake, every pie, every brownie, every cookie, every torte, every layer cake, every mousse (except our carrot cake and rugalech) is homemade right here in our little deli. This way we can carefully monitor the Katzinger's Delicatessen Dessert Philosophy - If you're going to splurge, make it well worth it. This way we can be certain only the finest ingredients are used - imported chocolate, sweet cream butter, heavy cream. We want every bite to be worth the indulgence. Though we always have several desserts on hand, please allow 72 hours advance notice for specific dessert orders.
Turtle Brownie -Our most popular brownie.  Rich chocolate surrounding gooey caramel, studded with chocolate chips and walnuts. 1.75
Fudgie Brownie -The deepest, densest bittersweet chocolate brownie imaginable.  Contains no nut products. 1.75
Stealer Brownie -A turtle brownie maxed with an additional layer of peanut butter filling...even gooier. 1.75
Blondie Brownie -A chocolate chip cookie in a bar. 1.75
New York Cheese Cake -A half pound of creamy cheese sweet goodness in every slice. 3.75
Carrot Cake -Dark and spicy with a cream cheese frosting 3.25
Rugalech - cream cheese/ butter cookies rolled with a variety of fillings - really yummy .95each

11.99/lb.
 

Specialty Desserts - changing daily. All homemade except carrot cake and rugalech. Give us 48 hours for special requests.